Peaceful Societies

Alternatives to Violence and War

News and Reviews

Tanya Tagaq Urges Inuit Cooperation


Tanya Tagaq, the well-known Canadian throat singer, emphasized to an audience in St. John’s, Newfoundland, last week the importance of Inuit unity and reconciliation. In contrast to her normally guttural style of singing, Tagaq spoke softly. Nonetheless, as the keynote speaker at an Inuit Studies Conference, which was held on the campus of the Memorial University of Newfoundland, she presented her ideas forcefully.

Tanya Tagaq

Tanya Tagaq, Inuit throat singer (Image by Nomo Michael Hoefner in Wikimedia, Creative Commons license)

An article in Nunatsiaq Online indicated that Tagaq is becoming an outspoken advocate for the indigenous rights of the Inuit, condemning the colonial policies and institutionalized racism that persist in her country. Raised in Cambridge Bay, she has become famous for her unique style of throat singing, but she is going beyond that.

Tagaq advocated that the Inuit should take charge of their own destiny. She called on all of them to ignore their differences and concentrate on developing their society together. She told her audience that people everywhere are trying to knock down the Inuit. Instead, she urged, “[we should] take these things into our own hands and demand change.” All too often the Inuit criticize one another for their failings, such as the fact that their young people are losing their language, Inuktitut. Instead, she argued, they should deal with this problem through the processes of sharing and learning together.

Two Inuit girls enjoying being together

Two Inuit girls enjoying being together (Photo by Rosemary Gilliat taken in 1960 in Frobisher Bay, now Iqaluit, in Flickr, Creative Commons license)

She strongly condemned the policies of the recent past when Canadian government agencies required Inuit children to attend residential schools in the provinces to the south of their Arctic homes. “What was done to children in residential school was so disturbing, it’s hard to talk about,” she said to her audience. “Years and years of trauma and torture and then sending them home with no language and no ability to parent,” she added, as if the cruelty is still hard to believe.

The news story does not indicate if Tagaq mentioned the work of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada, whose final report, issued in June last year, acknowledged the massive amounts of testimonies about the injustices perpetrated by the government and the proposals to finally heal the Inuit communities of their social and psychological injuries. The 94 recommendations of the commission were directed at actions governments in Canada should take.

She showed slides of her home community, Cambridge Bay, and her favorite places in that town when she was a child. She showed a picture of her own infant daughter posed next to a dead seal, an image which caused a storm of protest among animal lovers who are opposed to Inuit hunting the cute-looking animals. The anti-sealing forces protested volubly, but Tagaq was not swayed by the death threats and the petitions to take her children away from her.

An Inuit hunter skinning a ringed seal

An Inuit hunter skinning a ringed seal (Photo by Ansgar Walk in Wikipedia, Creative Commons license)

She argued that seal hunting has always been an essential source of food for her people. “Before the seal ban, we were thriving, being able to provide for our families and buy hunting supplies and pay rent by doing what we’ve always done,” she said. She argued that the people have a right to secure food for themselves.

Tagaq appeared barefoot on the stage, as she often does when she gives concerts, and she had her little girl Inuuja beside her. The audience gave her a standing ovation.


Poetry of the Buid


The ancient poetry, called ambahan, of the two Mangyan societies living near the southern end of Mindoro Island effectively conveys their daily concerns and their idealized social relationships. The Philippine Daily Inquirer last week described the peaceful social conditions, as well as the poetry, of the Buid and their neighbors, the Hanunoo.

Part of the mountainous Buid territory in San Jose, Occidental Mindoro, Philippines

Part of the mountainous Buid territory in San Jose, Occidental Mindoro, Philippines (Photo by Allan Siquioco on Panoramio, Creative Commons license)

Rita Ledesma, the journalist, briefly reviewed the history of the Mangyan peoples. Before the Spanish arrived, Mangyans lived all over Mindoro but as the invading Filipinos settled in the coastal lowlands, the seven or eight Mangyan groups retreated up into the mountains. For at least 400 years, the Buid have lived in the interior mountains near the southern end of the island. Each of the Mangyan societies, including the Buid and the Hanunoo, speak different languages, but only those two also preserve the ambahan.

Ms. Ledesma focused on the peacefulness of the two Mangyan groups. She repeated the comments of Emily Catapang, the executive director of the Mangyan Heritage Center in the city of Calapan, an institution founded to preserve and promote Mangyan cultures. According to Ms. Catapang, the Mangyans are “a peace-loving people. Family togetherness is deeply valued.” She described how elders settle conflicts and how they use leaves as symbols of the different candidates when they conduct elections. For instance, if a male candidate for office has adopted a mango leaf as his symbol, his supporters will each bring a mango leaf to the electoral assembly.

A Buid boy

A Buid boy (Screenshot from the video “Brutus, Ang Paglalakbay (Brutus: The Journey) Teaser” on Vimeo, Creative Commons license)

Ms. Catapang added that minor crimes were rare before modern technologies that depend on electricity, such as televisions, arrived in the villages. For instance, a film about illegal logging by Buid youngsters in 2008 entitled “Brutus” caused some controversy. But Ms. Catapang recognized that changes are occurring. Secondary schools are teaching the young people their native languages, as well as Tagalog and English, and, at least for the Buid and the Hanunoo, the Mangyan script. “Clearly there is progress, but a sweet contentment is also disappearing,” she said.

The Inquirer piece described the preservation and contemporary uses of the ambahans. They are still preserved in their ancient script on bamboo tubes, which are left outdoors to be used and read by others. The people hold ambahan sessions that often last all night or over a weekend. During these poetry readings, the Buid or Hanunoo will gather and socialize, laughing, whispering, chanting and composing almost endlessly.

The people build on each others feelings and thoughts as expressed in their poetry, without thinking much about who owns the verses. They all share the understandings of what they are saying as well as their intuitions about the meanings of the lines. Quint Delgado Fansler, a youthful idealist, described the Mangyan people to the journalist: “Culture changes. Heritage does not. The significance of Mangyan life is that it represents a living pre-Hispanic culture.”

Mangyans dancing

Mangyans dancing (Photo by Colin and Sarah Northway on Flickr, Creative Commons license)

The journalist, Ms. Ledesma, expressed her admiration for the Mangyan cultures evocatively: “Mangyans have been dancing with the winds of happiness and ease for hundreds of years.” She devoted several paragraphs in her article to the eminent scholar of ambahan studies, the Dutch anthropologist Antoon Postma, and his daughter Anya Postma, who is carrying on his scholarship related to the ancient form of poetic expression.

Anya learned from her Hanunoo mother the culture of the people, according to The Inquirer, such as spinning, weaving, designing textiles, basketry, and beadwork. She herself described her upbringing in the introductory paragraphs about her Hanunoo family in an undated paper she presented at a conference within the past few years. Antoon, a missionary priest for the Society of the Divine Word, was assigned in 1958 to work on Mindoro, where he fell in love with the Mangyan people and their culture, particularly the ambahans.

After 30 years he left the priesthood and married a Hanunoo woman. Anya was their first child. She and her siblings were raised in a home where the parents spoke only Hanunoo. “He wanted to make sure the Mangyans would accept his children as one of them, even though we don’t quite look exactly like them,” she wrote in her paper.

postma-coverShe described her father’s ambahan studies and his analysis of them, but it is better to turn to his own work to gain an insight into the nature of the poetry. His book Treasure of a Minority (1972) describes the ambahan in detail and, perhaps best of all, provides numerous examples of the poems, with English translations. While he described and translated the ambahan of the Hanunoo specifically, he made it clear that most of what he wrote would apply equally well to the Buid.

In his introductory comments, Postma defined the ambahan as a form of poetic expression that has seven syllable lines and rhyming end syllables. It is usually presented in a chanting style, though without musical accompaniment or any defined pitch. The purpose of the poem is to express allegorically the situation that the poet feels himself or herself to be in at the moment. The seven syllable rule is often accomplished by contractions or expansions of words to make the line have the proper number of syllables. Rhyming of the end syllables is essential, Postma wrote. A video on YouTube covers some of the major points Postma made in his book and reproduces a few of his translations of Hanunoo ambahans.

Postma noted that an ambahan may appear to be a nature poem about birds, trees, insects or flowers, but there are many different levels of meanings. One example he gave is that a poem about avoiding getting stung while taking honey from bees may have allegorical meanings such as the importance of watching out when you climb a mountain—or being careful when you go to the parents of a woman you love to ask for her hand in marriage.

He said that the traditional Hanunoo and Buid recitations of ambahans are of poems that have been handed down through the generations, not of recently created poems. At least, that is what the persons doing the chanting will say. Postma made it clear that the people were, in fact, creating new ambahans, but they were not admitting it. Also, different groups of people have their own groups of poetry—children, for instance, have ambahans written specifically for the interests of kids.

Postma wrote, “The ambahan is primarily a poem of social character; it finds its true existence in society (p.14).” It served practical purposes, such as the education of children, the courting of young lovers, the need of visitors for food, or the expressions of farewell by departing relatives. It helped strengthen their peacefulness.

His daughter Anya made it clear in her recent paper that those values still apply. The ambahan, she wrote, “portrays the Mangyans’ values of family, relationships, trust in nature, [and] respect for others…”



Older News and Reviews

News and reviews of publications relating to peaceful societies—and sometimes to related topics—are normally posted here on Thursday mornings (U.S. time). Older news and reviews for the year are listed on the 2016 page, and ones from previous years are listed on the News and Reviews 2004 page, the 2005 page, the 2006 page, the 2007 page, the 2008 page, the 2009 page, the 2010 page, the 2011 page, the 2012 page, the 2013 page, the 2014 page and the 2015 page. All stories are also included in the News and Reviews Subject Listing. They are listed at the bottom of each society entry in the Encyclopedia of Selected Peaceful Societies, after the heading: Updates: News and Reviews. News and reviews about peacefulness in general are referred to from the bottom of the Facts page, while news stories about this website are linked from the About This Website page. News and Reviews can also be found with the search bar.